Title

LOCAL GOVERNMENT ASSOCIATION

LGA review should show us warts and all

I am a huge supporter of the Local Government Association but it struggles to speak with one voice when it is criticising its own, writes Heather Jameson.

I am a huge supporter of the Local Government Association.

I absolutely believe that the local government world is a better place for having a single voice – and I am in favour of most of what it does.

As the Peer Review points out, if the LGA didn't exist, we would have to invent it.

The report does a great job of highlighting some of the best bits of the LGA and it claims the Graph of Doom, 100 days, and Rewiring Local Government reports showcase local government lobbying at its best.

However, the report is balanced – if somewhat politely.

It doesn't scrimp on highlighting the problems – some of which are inherent in the nature of the organisation.

It acknowledges that its diversity and consensus are its greatest strength and its greatest weakness.

On sector-led improvement, the Peer Review suggests the LGA needs to make reviews harder-hitting, intervene even where they are not wanted, and speak out against service failure.

The current consultation may provide some answers.

But as an association, reliant on subscriptions and consensus, the LGA struggles to speak with one voice when it is criticising its own and fails to bite the hands that feeds it.

The report is no doubt beautifully drafted to balance the criticisms with the praise – but they are there.

My understanding is that it was drafted several times in the six weeks between the initial findings and the final report – but I am told that was the LGA's opportunity to feed back.

What concerns me is the LGA comment on the report – which highlights the positives but fails to acknowledge any problems.

The review was initiated after Labour group leader Jim McMahon came into post last July – yet it was only conducted in January and only reporting now.

It smacks of a body dragging its heels.

For an organisation which peer reviews councils, and which is considering making reviews mandatory, I would have liked to have seen all the warts as the LGA showed local government just how Peer Reviews should be done.

But, as Cllr McMahon has suggested, what happens next will be the real test.

LOCAL GOVERNMENT ASSOCIATION

LGA: Outcomes framework should be expanded

By Neil Merrick | 30 September 2025

A proposed framework for assessing the effectiveness of councils should be expanded to cover all public sector bodies, the Local Government Association (LGA)...

LOCAL GOVERNMENT ASSOCIATION

Ministers' question time

By Jonathan Carr-West | 30 September 2025

Jonathan Carr-West looks at the reorganisation proposals submitted to the Government, and the questions now facing ministers.

LOCAL GOVERNMENT ASSOCIATION

Government axes cohesion fund

By Dan Peters | 30 September 2025

The Government has insisted it is ‘absolutely committed to bridging the divides between our communities’ despite axing a cohesion fund launched after 2024’s ...

LOCAL GOVERNMENT ASSOCIATION

Renewing democratic leadership

By Dr Sonia Bussu | 29 September 2025

Dr Jason Lowther and Dr Sonia Bussu examine how councillors can foster democratic innovations to bridge the gap between citizens and institutions.

Heather Jameson

Popular articles by Heather Jameson