The moment of truth on local government reform (LGR) is approaching for Andy Burnham, so time to ask: what happened to that ‘pause and review'? There was certainly a ‘pause', but as for anything that might be considered a review: assessing an evidence base for LGR; exploring overseas experiences, especially how local government is structured and operates in Germany, as Andy Burnham has expressed interest in their system; or any form of genuine reconsideration of the process – nothing!
So why ‘pause and review' at all? With an increasing number of councils threatening legal action, maybe the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (MHCLG) concluded, in legal terms, it stood on dodgy ground. That conclusion would not be surprising, given the lack of substance in the reasons given in July 2026 for LGR in the 21 shire counties in England, two days before Andy Burnham became Prime Minister. What emerges is an increasing desperation to simply get the job done, in whatever state, by 2029 - hence the five ‘minded to' decisions following the Budget adding more inconsistency to an already chaotic process.
