Title

LOCAL GOVERNMENT ASSOCIATION

Peer reviews should 'stretch' councils - LGA

Corporate peer challenges (CPC) should ‘stretch’ councils so they get the most out of them, the chairman of the Local Government Association’s (LGA) improvement and innovation board has said.

Corporate peer challenges (CPC) should ‘stretch' councils so they get the most out of them, the chairman of the Local Government Association's (LGA) improvement and innovation board has said.

Cllr Paul Bettison's comments come after an independent evaluation of CPCs by Cardiff University last year found some councils would have welcomed the reports they received to have been ‘more critical and incisive'.

One chief executive told researchers that their written report had been ‘sanitised' and ‘trivialised some of the issues,' adding: ‘It was about not wishing to apportion blame, not wishing to embarrass or reflect badly upon anybody.'

Cllr Bettison admitted that some peer teams stretched councils more than others but he also stressed the reviews were not inspections, adding: ‘It would be helpful for the sector if more people understood it's not stormtroopers coming in.'

The Cardiff review urged the sector to be ‘more honest about the issues being faced and resist attempting to alter the content or messages in the report'.

It read: ‘Some of the examples we read seemed to be designed to show the councils in the best light rather than pointing to what it wanted to achieve from the CPC.

'Without an honest self-assessment, time can be wasted by the CPC team trying to second guess exactly what the council wants from the process.

‘There is also a responsibility on councils to get out of the inspection mind set where achievements were sold to inspectors and clearly explain where they need support to help make improvements.'

One peer suggested some her colleagues might be too sympathetic and moderate their judgements or ‘give councils more credit if they are nice people and clearly trying'.

They told The MJ: ‘Peer challenges sometimes hold back from delivering hard-to-hear messages. I've witnessed it.

‘In my experience, peer challenge teams where the dominant team member has been a chief executive have been more challenging and specific in their feedback than when the leader member has been the dominant one.'

LOCAL GOVERNMENT ASSOCIATION

Giant steps to devolution and growth

By Henry Kippin | 19 November 2026

Henry Kippin shows how John Coltrane and other jazz greats can point the way to building state capacity at a local and regional level.

LOCAL GOVERNMENT ASSOCIATION

The great consultancy rip off

By Anonymous | 19 November 2026

I have spent a career working for top-tier firms and have seen first-hand how they’re able to fleece public clients, says our anonymous consultant.

LOCAL GOVERNMENT ASSOCIATION

Energy security starts local: why councils should invest in generation

By Eamon Grimes | 19 November 2026

To build long-term resilience, local authorities must work with partners and invest in local energy generation, writes Eamon Grimes.

LOCAL GOVERNMENT ASSOCIATION

LGR: In pursuit of transformational progress

By Martin Ford | 18 November 2026

England’s councils face uncertainty, capacity pressures and political challenges amid delayed reform, including the risks a section 114 might come into play....

Dan Peters

Popular articles by Dan Peters

-->