FINANCE

This is not devolution – this is not even centralism

‘Once the poster-child for devolution, Manchester is now being treated as the bad boy of politics – on the naughty step for daring to ask for a good deal for its residents’, says Heather Jameson.

Central government has not covered itself in glory when it comes to the response to the COVID crisis – but it is rapidly back-tracking on devolution too.

Most of the devolution deals we have had so far have been more an exercise in PR and window dressing than a true commitment to meaningful decentralisation.  We have moved from the language of the Northern Powerhouse to levelling up – but when it comes to local lockdowns, we are all levelling down.

The extraordinary events of the past few days, which saw Boris Johnson go head to head with Manchester Metro Mayor Andy Burnham, has shown a government that supports devolution only when it suits them.

When it comes to localism, and the Prime Minister's pledge to create bespoke local lockdowns – different in every area – how can the Government go on to argue that Manchester can't get more money than Lancashire or Liverpool?

Mr Johnson may have misunderstood the meaning of ‘bespoke' – not to mention the concept of levelling up.

The North South divide has become a chasm that the government is refusing to bridge for the sake of £5m, while it throws money at the NHS, empty Nightingale hospitals and track and trace systems with a track record of failure when local services could have done the job at a fraction of the cost.

I look forward to the inevitable National Audit Office conclusions that are yet to unfold.

Once the poster-child for devolution, Manchester is now being treated as the bad boy of politics – on the naughty step for daring to ask for a good deal for its residents.

But perhaps the biggest faux pas of the Government so far was revealed by Manchester City Council leader Sir Richard Leese, who revealed in the now-viral clip that the Government planned to pick off council leaders one by one. Divide and rule may not work in Manchester.

Meanwhile, in London, the Government has threatened to take over Transport for London unless the Mayor raises council tax.

This is not devolution. This is not even centralism. This is a Government punishing people over politics.  

FINANCE

Reform of SEND cannot come quickly enough

By Simon Edwards | 05 June 2025

With deficits increasing and liabilities for SEND accruing interest on the existing debt, this issue can no longer be ducked, says Simon Edwards. 'This is wh...

FINANCE

The impacts and risks of immigration and skills policies

By Oliver Lodge | 05 June 2025

Closer collaboration across Government departments and local authorities is vital to securing the benefits of immigration and protecting workers, says Oliver...

FINANCE

The cap doesn't fit

By Justin Griggs | 05 June 2025

Capping some or all parish and town councils would seriously threaten their effectiveness and undermine the broader agenda of devolution and community empowe...

FINANCE

Councils' watershed moment

By Martin Ford | 05 June 2025

Next week’s Spending Review will have huge implications for the future finances of local government. Martin Ford looks at what we know so far, and the key qu...

Heather Jameson

Popular articles by Heather Jameson