Title

BOOK REVIEW

Dirty tricks at the crossroads

Mick Hamer’s book goes back in time to set out the story of The MJ’s historic trams exposé. Here, he reveals what he uncovered.

Robert Donald (no picture credit – out of copyright)

Robert Donald (no picture credit – out of copyright)

When I started the research for my book, The Great Tramways Conspiracy, I had a simple question: Why did Britain's trams disappear? I did not expect a simple answer, but was taken aback by the dirty tricks I uncovered.

I found that trams were the victims of a deceitful public relations technique that is currently known as astroturfing. Today the phenomenon is rife on social media, where vested interests fake grassroots movements, hence the term.

Long before astroturf and social media existed, The MJ published what can fairly claim to be the earliest exposé of astroturfing. The discovery was exciting, because back in the 1980s I regularly freelanced for The MJ and Robert Donald, the great journalist who founded the journal in 1893, was still part of the office folklore.

In the 1890s Britain's tramways were in a state of flux. Technology was changing, with electric trams replacing horse power. Ownership was changing too. Early tramways were mostly operated by private companies on 21-year leases. As the leases fell due, many councils opted to take over the trams and run them directly.

When the papers received True Progressive's epistle, it came with a handwritten covering letter on the notepaper of the Electrical Power Distribution Company, a major BET subsidiary. This covering letter promised that the company would pay handsomely if newspapers published True Progressive's letter.

Glasgow's takeover in 1894 was spectacularly successful. The city put on more trams, improved wages, cut fares and made a tidy profit, which helped to keep down the rates. The only losers were the shareholders in the old company. Donald was a staunch supporter of municipal enterprise.

But British Electric Traction (BET), the foremost private operator, had other ideas. It bought up a series of horse tramways with the intention of electrifying them. Its corporate strategy was to corner the market and create a sprawling monopoly that stretched from power stations to trams.

By 1901, BET had gained the right to supply electricity for lighting and trams over a large part of North London and was negotiating to take over the horse tramways. But its strategy was threatened by the plan of the urban district council of Hendon to build its own power station.

In June 1901, several newspapers in North London carried identical letters about Hendon's plans to run a power station from someone using the pen name ‘True Progressive' – Progressive being the name used by the Liberal Party in London. The letters claimed that Hendon's power station would put threepence on the rates.

When the papers received True Progressive's epistle, it came with a handwritten covering letter on the notepaper of the Electrical Power Distribution Company, a major BET subsidiary. This covering letter promised that the company would pay handsomely if newspapers published True Progressive's letter.

The MJ exposed this deceit. The letter ‘was intended to be taken as the contribution of a local ratepayer', wrote Donald, and ‘True Progressive' was unmasked as a BET employee.

Donald said that BET aimed ‘to secure an absolute monopoly of electric light and tramways' in North London.

The struggle between BET and municipal enterprise came to a head the following year in Birmingham, when the local council held a referendum before promoting a parliamentary Bill, which would allow it to run the city's trams. BET made strenuous efforts to thwart the takeover, pouring large sums of money into the campaign.

Voters were rounded up in local pubs, taken to the polling station and given a shilling to vote against the council's plans. Despite the wholesale bribery, the council won a decisive victory with two-thirds of voters approving its plans. ‘All friends of honest government and municipal progress will rejoice,' commented The MJ.

Not long after this setback, BET retired from the fray and gave up the struggle to keep trams private.

By the 1920s, nine out of 10 trams were run by councils. At the time more people travelled by tram than by bus. Trams then faced a second outburst of astroturfing, which seemed to owe something to the earlier campaign. Again and again, letters to the press claimed that trams were obsolete and should be scrapped and replaced by buses. It was an orchestrated campaign and the writers mostly used pseudonyms.

One of the more prolific writers, who signed his letters, was a barrister who was freelancing as a publicist for the Shell oil company. The circumstantial evidence points to Shell being the financial muscle behind the astroturfing.

In 1928, the Government set up a Royal Commission on Transport. It accepted newspaper claims that trams were obsolete. In 1931, it recommended abolishing trams. The commission's report was a watershed moment. Over the following 30 years, trams virtually vanished from the British mainland.

Toward the end of its work, the commission had gained a new member – Sir Robert Donald. Now knighted and one of the most respected editors on Fleet Street, Donald revealed the inside story in an article for The MJ. The commission was prejudiced against trams partly because of its ‘opposition to municipal trading'.

The Great Tramways Conspiracy, by Mick Hamer, is published by Pen and Sword. Price £29.99. ISBN: 9781036143343

BOOK REVIEW

Post-Grenfell progress still under scrutiny

By Dan Peters | 28 October 2026

The Building Safety Bill strengthens council enforcement powers on unsafe cladding, but funding and staff shortages threaten remediation progress. Dan Peters...

BOOK REVIEW

Planning for the worst

By Martin Ford | 22 September 2026

As the UK faces a myriad of large-scale threats that only grows longer with each passing year, how well equipped is local government to cope? Martin Ford rep...

BOOK REVIEW

Councils bulk buying housing from developers to ease pressures

By Paul Marinko | 03 September 2026

With the housing market stalled, councils are bulk buying homes intended for private sale at huge discounts in a bid to ease their temporary accommodation co...

BOOK REVIEW

Quango conundrum

By Ann McGauran | 27 August 2026

Rewiring the State promises a serious look at whether arm’s-length bodies’ powers and funding should be handed to local leaders or returned to ministerial d...

-->