CHARTERED INSTITUTE OF PUBLIC FINANCE AND ACCOUNTANCY

We can't just kick the can down the road

The recently revised advice promoted by CIPFA rightly helps finance directors to give their own organisations more opportunity than ever to try and avoid a s114, says Gary Fielding.

It is understandable that there are further calls for councils to be able to balance the books over a longer period. Comparisons have been made with the NHS, which can run up deficits. While true in principle, health colleagues are often managed to within an inch of their lives on how they can hit a control total by 31 March and I have seen little by way of multi-year flexibility, planning or realism on deliverability in Whitehall. This is not something I think local government should look at too longingly.

The recently revised s114 advice promoted by the Chartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy (CIPFA) rightly helps finance directors to give their own organisations more opportunity than ever to try and avoid a s114. That is one reason why we have not seen more s114s.

However, I suspect a multi-year balanced budget with deficits rolled forward could be just too tempting for some and an incoming administration may face some early unwelcome challenges – remember there are no NHS elections. Whether it is a safe strategy to hold off savings plans would inevitably become more subjective and the role of the finance director would be harder still in the face of a determined political leadership.

Councils can already balance a year off by using reserves where there is confidence that there is a longer-term plan to reach sustainability. If a council finds itself without reserves, or other measures to buy time, then it is at the higher end of the risk spectrum so can least afford to defer decisions on the basis that salvation may be around the corner. What if it isn't?

The future has never looked more uncertain and I would suggest a successful budget strategy for the next few years is one that ensures survival but not just by conveniently kicking the can down the road.

Gary Fielding is corporate director of strategic resources at North Yorkshire CC and president of the Society of County Treasurers

CHARTERED INSTITUTE OF PUBLIC FINANCE AND ACCOUNTANCY

The new health duty on strategic authorities: getting it right

By Tom Lloyd Goodwin | 27 June 2025

If designed and implemented effectively, the new health duty on strategic authorities could play a crucial role in advancing health equity alongside economic...

CHARTERED INSTITUTE OF PUBLIC FINANCE AND ACCOUNTANCY

More than a service

By Louise Hayes | 27 June 2025

As Shared Lives week comes to a close, Louise Hayes explains how the scheme is transforming social care in Surrey.

CHARTERED INSTITUTE OF PUBLIC FINANCE AND ACCOUNTANCY

The secret ingredient is community crowdfunding

By Frank Kibble | 27 June 2025

In London Climate Action Week, Frank Kibble explains how everyday climate activism is being being funded by communities - with support from their council.

CHARTERED INSTITUTE OF PUBLIC FINANCE AND ACCOUNTANCY

With opportunity comes great responsibility

By Laura Murphy | 27 June 2025

Laura Murphy and Andrew Stilwell look at the importance of strong, collaborative leadership as organisations navigate through this new era of digital transfo...

Popular articles by Gary Fielding