Title

INNOVATION

Collaboration: a look at the flipside

To foster the innovation required, leaders must strike the right balance between collaboration and individual decision-making, says director at Tile Hill Executive Recruitment Greg Hayes.

Collaboration is universally seen as an essential leadership skill. It can improve decision-making, problem-solving, relationships, and innovation. Job profiles and advertisements are littered with this desirable attribute, but what is the flipside, and can you have too much of a good thing?

From a decision-making perspective, a body of evidence suggests unique idea generation suffers within a group setting, and this increases as the size of the group grows. Given that innovation is touted as one of the solutions to the impending challenge facing local government, the leadership trick will be harnessing the benefits of collaboration without stifling innovative thought. Too much emphasis on collaboration can lead to an absence of risk-taking and consensus-based decisions. The diversification of leadership teams is improving, but groupthink remains a phenomenon that can lead to poor decisions.

To foster the innovation required, leaders must strike the right balance between collaboration and individual decision-making.

Creating a culture where people are comfortable sharing ideas that are different from the majority view is part of it. As is celebrating different working styles, as not everybody collaborates in the same way. Accountability is an important consideration too. People are less likely to go with the flow and make poor decisions where accountability exists. And giving people clear expectations and outcomes for collaborating will make them much more likely to be effective and productive. Given that collaboration via email, instant messaging, phone, and video has risen by 50% in the past decade and consumes 85% of most people's working week, leaders must ensure it is purposeful and done effectively. It is harder and more contrived to collaborate post-pandemic, which can lead to greater demands on people's time and burnout. For better decisions, more innovation, and a more fulfilled workforce, let's collaborate on the right things at the right time.

Greg Hayes is a director at Tile Hill Executive Recruitment

This article is sponsored content for The MJ

INNOVATION

Will Makerfield change Westminster?

By Donna Hall | 19 June 2026

Donna Hall asks if Andy Burnham can reconnect power with people.

INNOVATION

Turning neighbourhood health from policy into practice

By Helen Bromley | 19 June 2026

The chairs of Cheshire and Merseyside’s All Together Fairer Board and Neighbourhoods Task and Finish Group set out how the subregion’s neighbourhood approach...

INNOVATION

Seizing the opportunity of local government reorganisation

By Cllr Richard Wright | 19 June 2026

Rather than recreating existing structures, councils should use reorganisation to transform services, strengthen local accountability and improve outcomes fo...

INNOVATION

The leadership promotion trap

By Ryan Miller | 18 June 2026

Ryan Miller notes that the skills required to perform in a role are often different to those required to lead people – and the most successful organisations ...

Greg Hayes

Popular articles by Greg Hayes