Title

FINANCE

No consensus on replacement of 'unfair' council tax

Opinion is split on what should replace Scotland’s ‘unfair’ council tax system, new analysis has found.

Opinion is split on what should replace Scotland's ‘unfair' council tax system, new analysis has found.

Two-thirds of people responding to the Commission on Local Tax Reform said council tax was ‘regressive' and impacted negatively on vulnerable households. 

Most people also said there was a disconnect between local priorities and the way that local taxation operated.

However, there was no consensus on an alternative, with a reformed local property tax, local income tax and land value tax all being presented as options.

Respondents did say the efficiency and stability of the present system should be retained in any alternative system of local taxation.

Scottish local government minister Marco Biagi, who co-chairs the commission, said: ‘The findings of our formal call for evidence suggest very strongly that there are a majority of people in Scotland who agree that the current system of council tax is unfair and in need of reform.

‘However, what is also clear is that there are a wide range of opinions as to what a potential replacement for the present system would look like and operate, echoing many of the views that we have heard from the more than 4,000 people who have engaged with us so far.'

FINANCE

Crossing the capability chasm

By Simon Christian | 20 January 2026

Local government finance leaders are very clear about what they want to focus on, but there is a widening gap between strategic aspiration and operational ba...

FINANCE

Is English devolution in a holding pattern hiatus?

By David Blackman | 20 January 2026

What impact will the delays to the mayoral elections in Greater Essex, Hampshire and the Solent, Norfolk & Suffolk and Sussex & Brighton have on devolution? ...

FINANCE

A bit more 'no, minister' is needed

By Michael Burton | 20 January 2026

A succession of government U-turns over badly-considered policies suggest the Whitehall machine is under-performing in its duty to give practical advice to m...

FINANCE

What CIPFA's Financial Resilience Index reveals about risk and reform

By Florence Bastos | 20 January 2026

CIPFA and Infoshare+’s Financial Resilience Index shows that better planning horizons will not be enough on their own to bring back long-term financial susta...

Popular articles by Laura Sharman