Title

HEALTH

Councils win legal battle with health boards

Health boards in Wales ‘misinterpreted’ the law over who is responsible for paying for nurses to deliver social care in residential homes, a court has ruled.

Health boards in Wales ‘misinterpreted' the law over who is responsible for paying for nurses to deliver social care in residential homes, a court has ruled.

The four-year legal dispute began when health boards in Wales decided to pay a flat weekly rate to nurses, excluding payments for non-nursing care time and for time such as supervised breaks.

Yesterday, the Supreme Court ruled in the 21 councils' favour, calling for the two parties to renegotiate the payments.

The Welsh NHS Confederation, on behalf of health boards in Wales, said it accepted the decision.

Vanessa Young, director of the Welsh NHS Confederation, said: ‘The judgement is the conclusion of a long and complex legal case, which was instigated by a legal challenge from the care sector.  

‘It has never been about winners or losers, but about seeking clarity on complex points of law and how they apply to the funding arrangements for those receiving nursing care in a care home setting.  

‘The outcome reflects the complexity of the case and the need for all parties to work together to agree the balance of responsibility for funding care in what is essentially a grey area of the law.'

 

HEALTH

Good job we've been practising partnership working

By Mike Dearing | 29 January 2026

As the local government sector undergoes widespread change, the forging of relationships will be as important as the structures that emerge, writes Mike Dear...

HEALTH

The stakes for democracy are high and the challenges of local governance remain

By Kersten England | 26 January 2026

Kersten England predicts continued social and political turbulence through 2026 and says collaboration and reciprocity between communities and local governan...

HEALTH

Tips for the residential care top-ups

By Lisa Morgan | 14 January 2026

As care costs continue to increase, local authorities must ensure their top-up fee processes for people who need residential care are sound, lawful and well ...

HEALTH

'Exporting' the housing challenge

By Paul Marinko | 14 January 2026

The growing tendency of councils to use ‘out of area’ placements to discharge their housing responsibilities is increasing tension between local authorities....

Popular articles by Laura Sharman