Fiscal devolution - the moment has come

Chair of the Commons CLG Select Committee Clive Betts urges the Goverment to join forces with local authorities in advancing the fiscal devolution agenda in England.

For all the Chancellor's talk of Northern Powerhouses, and Labour's proposal to hand £30bn of Whitehall spending to local authorities, there are those still pressing for more.

Philip Collins, writing in The Times last week, said, "The one big financial reform that central government could offer, which it won't, is to change the money flows so that more of it is raised locally.

'Where there is money there is power,' he added. 'No Westminster politician is even suggesting anything so bold.'
 
Until now. My colleagues and I on the Communities and Local Government (CLG) Select Committee are calling for exactly that – the transfer of a range of tax raising powers to local authorities, including business rates, stamp duty, council tax and other smaller taxes and charges, together with greater flexibility to borrow for investment.
 
The MJ's own Campaign for Fiscal Freedom has highlighted the overwhelming need for more financial freedoms to help local authorities grow their economies.
 
England's cities and counties have repeatedly made a powerful case for decentralisation and fiscal devolution.
 
My committee's view is that when Scotland and Wales are being promised ever greater fiscal freedom, it is now up to Ministers and general election manifesto writers to show the same enthusiasm for devolution elsewhere in the UK—by allowing local communities in England to take greater control over how money is raised and spent in their areas. 
 
The people of New York, Frankfurt and Tokyo can be trusted with tax-raising powers. Why not those in London, Greater Manchester or the north-east?
 
Local areas know best how to stimulate their economies. With a wider range of revenue streams at their disposal, they would be able to make more of their own investment decisions—without having to lobby central Government for a hand-out every time. Local people could reap the rewards through increased tax take, which could then be reinvested in their areas.
 
Fiscal devolution in England is an idea whose moment has arrived. The time has come for Government to join with local authorities to push this agenda forward.
 
Clive Betts, chair of the Communities and Local Government (CLG) Select Committee and Labour MP Sheffield South East
 
The CLG committee report Devolution in England: the case for local government is available via www.parliament.uk/clgcom.

Time to empower the places that matter

By Ravi Gurumurthy | 16 May 2025

Labour's Neighbourhood Commission is not just good politics, but good policy says Ravi Gurumurthy.

Investment is required in every part of the country

By Ann McGauran | 16 May 2025

Positive steps on local government finance need to be backed up by investment and cost-of-living action, says Cllr Sir Stephen Houghton.

EXCLUSIVE: Push for local PACs slows amid Whitehall scepticism

By EXCLUSIVE by Dan Peters and Martin Ford | 15 May 2025

Support for establishing local versions of the Public Accounts Committee (PAC) across England is softening as the Government ponders whether to push the idea.

Why the Total Place bandwagon should roll again

By Michael Burton | 15 May 2025

John Denham was Labour’s communities secretary 15 years before Angela Rayner. He tells Michael Burton why he would not have embarked on wholescale local gove...

Popular articles by Clive Betts