What makes somewhere a good place to live? The Times recently named the nation's 10 happiest places. Alongside rating access to green spaces, amenities and job opportunities, respondents were asked how far they agreed with the statement: ‘I can be myself.'
It is a simple statement but one that speaks to the purpose of the state: to help create conditions in which people can live lives of their choosing, with the freedom, security and opportunity to realise their potential. It raises a question largely absent from the debate about Andy Burnham's Rewiring the State initiative. Why, exactly, are we rewiring it? And – crucially – who are we rewiring it for?
Focusing today's programme solely around where power sits misses the point about how power is exercised and who we think we are exercising it for. Defining the terms of prevention or inclusive growth is no shortcut to understanding how 21st-century people want to see and act for themselves.
Much of the state we are tasked with rewiring remains organised around post-war beliefs about society, economy and aspiration that passed with our grandparents' generation. The real work is no less than the remaking of national identities.
An upheaval of the self
An industrial economy, stable work, class identity, family, geography and community – post-war these provided relatively stable ways of understanding who people were.
These assumptions were neither benign nor universally shared. But the relationship between society and the institutions of the state was mutually reinforcing. Institutions reflected prevailing understandings of who we were and in turn helped reproduce them.
The state, in other words, could see. Not everyone, and certainly not equally, but it possessed a reasonably coherent understanding of the society it existed to serve.
Over subsequent decades, much of that unravelled. Economic restructuring, declining class identities, changing families, migration and demands for the emancipation of those previously excluded from the social contract have transformed how we understand ourselves and our possibilities.
In the early 1990s, sociologist Anthony Giddens observed the emergence of the self as a ‘reflexive project': our biographies increasingly constructed and reconstructed through experiences, relationships and choices, rather than simply inherited. His point was that the relationship between individuals and society has always been reflexive. What changed was the basis and intensity of that replication and what it was now yielding.
The assumptions and stories underpinning our post-war institutions have become increasingly inadequate at describing our lives and what we want from them. We see this reflected in the upheaval around us. From #MeToo's challenge to protected power relationships between men and women, to political mobilisation around identity and grievance, to the outrage and eco-anxiety of young people as the impact of AI and climate change intensifies – we are witnessing extraordinary contests over who we are, whose voices matter and who determine the future.
These are profoundly different phenomena, but each illustrates how identities can be challenged, reconstructed and mobilised. Sometimes this produces new freedoms, sometimes resentment and suspicion about who exactly the system is working for, if not us.
The state knows so much, but sees so little
It is a paradox that in recent years our institutions have acquired extraordinary information about us, yet still struggle to understand our lives. They can know our housing status, benefit entitlement, health or employment status without understanding how these circumstances connect, or what a person hopes to achieve.
This may help to explain declining institutional trust. When institutions no longer reflect people's experiences, people struggle to recognise themselves in those who govern them. This is more than administrative failure. It is a breakdown of the relationship through which institutions acquire legitimacy and people develop confidence in their capacity to shape their lives.
Devolution, fiscal reform and reconfigured accountabilities are necessary. So too is Cabinet secretary Antonia Romeo's recognition that Whitehall's structures and incentives must change.
But these are preconditions for transformation, not transformation itself. Pooling budgets will not necessarily produce a coherent understanding of people's lives. Prevention will achieve little if understood principally as managing demand rather than removing barriers to good lives. The pioneers of inclusive growth recognised that inclusion and growth were interdependent operative words. The state we need is one that promotes and produces these goals as a matter of routine.
Here lies the opportunity
If identities are continually constructed through experience, they can also be remade. The same reflexive capacity that allows identities to form around grievance and exclusion can support identities built around contribution, mutual obligation and shared achievement.
A woman entering secure work, a family whose difficulties are understood before they reach crisis or a young person getting help to come off benefits are not simply recipients of interventions. Each can acquire a different understanding of what is possible and their capacity to act.
Confidence enables action. Acting together builds relationships that create new possibilities, strengthening agency and belonging.
Grievance can feed on itself. But agency, when nourished, can also grow.
We should welcome the ambition to rewire the state. But we must not mistake its architecture for its purpose.
We cannot design a new state and impose it on society. Transformation must be reciprocal: institutions learning from people's lives while helping create possibilities for collective action and shared achievement.
The real challenge is to imagine, together, the lives we want to lead and to create institutions capable of helping us realise them.
Chris Naylor is managing director of Inner Circle Consulting and a former council chief executive
