Title

POLICY AND POLITICS

Isle of Wight Council 'dysfunctional', report finds

Isle of Wight Council faces serious governance failings and risks Government intervention unless urgent reforms are made, an independent report has warned.

(c) Panumas Yanuthai/Shutterstock.com

(c) Panumas Yanuthai/Shutterstock.com

Isle of Wight Council faces serious governance failings and risks Government intervention unless urgent reforms are made, an independent report has warned.

The review by governance expert Richard Penn highlighted a breakdown in trust between councillors and officers, allegations of bullying and poor adherence to the council's codes of conduct.

Penn described the council's culture as ‘dysfunctional' and said ‘inappropriate member behaviour was a symptom of wider organisational problems'.

He wrote: ‘While inappropriate member behaviour has been, to some extent, a trigger for this review it is clear to me there are issues that need to be addressed in respect of the organisation as an entity, and that what is required is a set of actions involving members and officers that will help to restore respect and trust between officers and members.'

The report urged ‘immediate action', including strengthening the council's standards processes, restoring mutual respect, and improving officer support and councillor training. 

It also called for a dedicated standards committee and for senior governance roles to be ‘elevated'.

Penn warned that without ‘rapid change the potential for Government intervention is a reality'.

Chief executive Wendy Perera said: ‘This report is a moment for reflection and renewal.'

 

POLICY AND POLITICS

Reform UK council hit by trebling of councillor conduct complaints

By Joe Lepper | 18 May 2026

Peers have raised concerns about the impact of increasing reports of negative member behaviour on staff morale and retention at a Reform UK-led council.

POLICY AND POLITICS

EXCLUSIVE: MHCLG working to overhaul Best Value

By Dan Peters | 14 May 2026

The Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (MHCLG) is working on a review and update of Best Value guidance, The MJ can reveal.

POLICY AND POLITICS

Turning more complex council politics into effective local governance

By Owen Mapley | 12 May 2026

Officer-member relationships matter more than ever in local government’s new reality, and the principle of mutual respect must be restated, says Owen Mapley.

POLICY AND POLITICS

New ADASS president's full in-tray

By Lee Peart | 11 May 2026

Newly elected president of the Association of Directors of Adult Social Services, Phil Holmes, shares his views on neighbourhood health, Integrated Care Boar...

Popular articles by William Eichler