REORGANISATION

Decent funding matters more than structure

Ben Page's advice – 'despite being normally very keen on surveys, public consultation and empowerment' – is to consult the sector on reorganisation, 'and then decide, and not to have a long drawn out process'.

(c) PredragLasica / Shutterstock.com

(c) PredragLasica / Shutterstock.com

The announcement of a White Paper on local government reform will excite lots of people in the sector, and a few thousand in each county, but few beyond. Sir John Banham, running one of England's re-organisations back in the 1990s, noted that a fully unitary solution for much of the country would get all-party support in Parliament, but cause ‘mayhem' when implemented. 

Maybe he was wrong. Successive governments have tended to unitaries, topped out with elected mayors, and so far mayhem has yet to arrive.

While devolution in principle is popular, whenever the English are offered a local authority with devolved tax-raising powers they reject it

My advice – despite being normally very keen on surveys, public consultation and empowerment – is to consult the sector and then decide, and not to have a long drawn out process.

When I was first working in the sector I would have of course demanded extensive independent polling, but more recently I am always amazed how relatively few people really care. The public worry about key local services, but not so much about local government's structure.

Local government remains more trusted than central government, but efficiency and keeping council tax bills down will trump the number of councillors. The public consistently support more local decision-making, but this has not led to a majority voting in local elections, or protesting at decades-long centralisation of control.

While devolution in principle is popular, whenever the English are offered a local authority with devolved tax-raising powers they reject it.

So getting on with it, providing clarity and promised multi-year funding deals, are probably positive. But looking at history, a few things stand out. The savings will probably be less than hoped for, and the costs of reorganisation greater than planned. The chances of greater public involvement with fewer bigger councils, is slight. And finally, decent funding matters more than structure.

You're welcome.

Ben Page is global chief executive of Ipsos

REORGANISATION

London remade

By Jonathan Werran | 04 July 2025

London has a golden opportunity to reset and reform the relationship between its boroughs and the mayoralty. Just how bold and radical this reform will be de...

REORGANISATION

Proud to serve the sector

By Louise Gittins | 03 July 2025

Writing in LGA Conference week, newly re-elected chair Cllr Louise Gittins reflects on the Government’s key announcements and says council leaders must have ...

REORGANISATION

Common sense Reform

By Paul Marinko | 03 July 2025

Reform UK is taking a measured approach to implementing change as the party takes charge of Durham Council, the authority’s new leader tells Paul Marinko.

REORGANISATION

Central and local government will transform the country for the better

By Georgia Gould | 03 July 2025

Writing in the week of the LGA Conference, Jim McMahon and Georgia Gould say this government was elected to deliver a decade of national renewal, and this si...

Ben Page

Popular articles by Ben Page